Dark Skies for Carragal

Carragal still has a night sky. From the lake reserve on a clear moonless night the Milky Way is bright enough to see your hand by.

The Society is not against lighting. We are against lighting that shines up instead of down.

The oval

In 2023 the Carragal Football Netball Club received a State grant for four 30-metre LED towers at the Recreation Reserve. We note:

  • The towers as installed are tilted 20 degrees above the design angle.
  • They are 5700 K. Dark sky organisations recommend 3000 K or warmer. The Australian Standard on the obtrusive effects of outdoor lighting, AS/NZS 4282, sets limits on spill and upward light, and we do not believe these towers have been measured against it.
  • On training nights they are routinely left on until 11 pm. Training finishes at 8.

Our measurements from the lake reserve, 4.5 km away:

Zenith, mag/arcsec²20° above town
Lights off21.821.1
Lights on21.519.4

We have written to the Shire (letter of 2 August 2023, reply of 14 November 2023, both available on request) and to the club. We ask that the towers be aimed down, turned off when the ground is empty, and fitted with the warm-white option at the next lamp replacement.

The Society wishes to make clear that this page represents the view of the Society and not necessarily of every committee member. (Added at the request of the Treasurer.)

W. Kessell, for the committee, August 2023. Revised D. Marr, 2025.